John Hood says he's "confused by the odd behavior" of the state NAACP and its leader, the Rev. William Barber, when it comes to their opposition to the changes going on in Wake County's schools.
In a column today, Hood, president of the conservative John Locke Foundation, notes all the actions that the NAACP has taken over Wake ending the diversity policy. But Hood said Barber didn't stage sit-in protests when other North Carolina school districts "years ago adopted student-assignment policies identical or similar to the policy Wake County is about to adopt."
"Why is Wake being singled out?," Hood writes. "Is it because its neighborhood-schools policy is being adopted resolutely by a conservative board rather than being adopted reluctantly by a liberal board bowing to public opinion and the clear direction of the federal courts? Is it, in other words, about politics rather than education?"
Barber is referenced as part of a larger column by Hood in which he also writes about the state's looming ban on sweepstakes gambling and Congressman Bob Etheridge's recent video confrontation.

Comments
I'm sure "confused" is John Hood's natural state...
Tue, 06/22/2010 - 23:12 — MarvinSchwartz...but in this case, I do agree with him on one salient point: Where has the NAACP been on other school districts seeking to end diversity, particularly Charlotte-Meck? This is simply opinion, but I think the interest in Wake has more to do with tearing down a voluntary model for diversity as opposed to reversing a court-ordered one like in CMS.
More important, and to Hood's point, why was the NAACP so tardy in getting involved in Wayne County, Rev. Barber's home, with the sorry state of Goldsboro High School? It was only after the good Reverend brought the heat to WCPSS that the NAACP took up the fight of Wayne County Schools' unwillingness to redraw attendance lines and lax open attendance policy that created a core of high-poverty, nearly all-black, poor-performing schools, that has been going on for 15+ years. But they're neighborhood schools, by goodness. And by the power of Tedesco, they shall heal themselves, right? Right? Fifteen years and the people of Goldsboro are still waiting...
Voluntary Model....what?
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 08:10 — JanisTangoThe only voluntary portion of the previous policy was to apply to other options. This by no means guaranteed you would get these options. This policy was primarily a forced busing policy with many families without viable choices except to leave the school system (which many did), or just stop complaining and allowing your kids to be bused past many schools to get to 'your' base option. Many families that did choose to apply for other options were discriminated against based on the 4 level approach they had for the magnet lottery. Most cities I have lived in truly had a voluntary diversity policy with their magnet system (this is not unique to Wake). Some voluntary magnet schools in a town I lived in previously had 75% African American and 25% white and other population. This would NEVER be allowed in Wake.
He's talking about the Wake
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 08:38 — virginiadareHe's talking about the Wake school board voluntarily integrating the schools back in the 70's rather than being forced to do so by court order as were CMS and many other southern systems. I think you're showing your ignorance of NC history. Wake County has been viewed as the symbol and a model of successful efforts to balance schools, which is why I believe Barber and his allies are fighting so hard now. If Wake County goes back to the de facto segregation of the past. there is no hope for other systems to move forward in eliminating very high poverty, racially-identifiable schools.
ARgh...
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 10:49 — Bob_Sconce(1) WHO has viewed Wake County as a "model of successful efforts to balance schools"? In what way were they successful?
(2) It's already been shown that Wake County is far more diverse than it was 40 years ago, with people of different races, religions and nationalities all living in the same neighborhoods. "De facto segregation" just isn't going to happen.
Too many organizations and
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 13:10 — virginiadareToo many organizations and scholars to mention have praised WCPSS, including the Century Foundation and CUBE. I know many of you belittle Gerald Grand and his book "No Bad Schools...", but he's right. Did you read the entire book? Raleigh could very easily be like Syracuse, full of very high poverty schools that no amount of money can fix. If Janis thinks the rim schools are "destroyed", wait until she sees the schools created by the new assignment zones. And we're not talking about diversity of races, religions and nationalities living in the same neighborhoods, which generally means they are of the same class and income levels. We are talking about segregation that was created by centuries of slavery and Jim Crow laws, creating divisions that have still not been overcome. It's what the Brown decision was all about. Housing patterns caused by red-lining and other methods of discrimination mean that most schools in SE Raleigh and other parts of the county will become very high poverty, racially identifiable schools, which WILL be de facto segregation.
So...
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 14:05 — Bob_SconceBasically a bunch of ivory-tower types? 9 times out of 10, that's absolutely the wrong set of people to keep happy.
You used the word 'model,' which implies that other districts are using WCPSS' diversity policy as a basis for their own. What other districts have modeled their assignment policies after WCPSS'? It seems that rather than being a model for other districts, WCPSS' policy is really something of a red-headed stepchild.
1) I viewed WCPSS as a
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 12:08 — user123451) I viewed WCPSS as a refreshing change from Atlanta where I grew up where White families were always on the move fleeing Black kids. I viewed WCPSS as good, integrated area where the courts did not need to merge the schools under force and where people of all races tolerated each other and let their kids go to school together. I viewed WCPSS as successful since most of the schools provided a decent education to all incomes and races which was not the case when I went to school and Black got short changed.
2) "De facto segregation" ... look at Wake which is only 50% White kids now. Look at the outliers - Green Hope 5% Black and Garner and Knightdale are 50% Black. All the White kids can not fit into Green Hope.
No matter how you want to
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 13:01 — aquaman4life68No matter how you want to view it:
1. court orders "integration"
OR...
2. local school board adopts "diversity policy" to integrate.
BOTh equals....parents do not have a choice and shuffling children around is the goal.
THIS IS THE KEY ISSUE...parents are tired of being picked apart and moved around. Simple as that!
If parents want not be moved
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 18:01 — user12345If parents want not be moved around than they need to get out out the Triangle ... I think they may have build 30-40 schools since I first moved here! ... vs. 1 new one every 30 years where I grew up.
Technically you might be correct
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 19:11 — g88ky07but, if you want not to be here as this system moves in a new real world direction, no one is stopping you, or others, from leaving yourselves!
As for the I grew up in Atlanta and whites ran at every turn to escape those not like them, what bull. I was born, raised and lived in ATL for decades and I don't EVER recall seeing anyone running from anyone else. At least not for the reasons you say.
And as for building 1 school in 30 years, not even close. Add some more digits to your 1.
Obviously you did not live
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 22:27 — user12345Obviously you did not live in Fulton or Dekalb county ... my school was 100% White when I started and 80% Black when I graduated ... do you think they just made up the term "White Flight"?
Here is a history lesson ..
Thanks for that detail.
Thu, 06/24/2010 - 08:49 — zandeThanks for that detail. Informative posts like that are why I read this blog. Understanding that kind of history is crucial to the decisions being made here in Wake.
The turmoil in Atlanta and
Thu, 06/24/2010 - 12:10 — user12345The turmoil in Atlanta and other cities caused by the mass migration of Whites should have happened in Raleigh in the 1970's with Raleigh being Black in the center surrounded by White suburbs ... that is what should have happened and so moving here I was amazed that White people still lived in town ... hopefully the new turmoil caused by the BOE will not start that process now ... I did think Dekalb's M2M program that let kids attend schools where they were a minority was interesting. A program like that might give Blacks access to some of the resources reserved today for White schools.
Ahhhhh, the history lesson
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 23:31 — g88ky07Actually I did live in Dekalb for several years, but did not go to school there.
Note to self, call parents first thing tomorrow and thank them for sheltering me from all the "white flight".
np ... many people on the
Thu, 06/24/2010 - 12:07 — user12345np ... many people on the blog are sheltered from what is going on around them.
Interesting...
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 12:22 — Bob_SconceI viewed WCPSS as successful since most of the schools provided a decent education to all incomes and races
So, you moved here with that belief. Do you still believe that's true (let's ignore any actions over the past 7 months)? It seems to me that the word 'most' should be replaced with 'a few'.
really?
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 12:14 — AngelaWEasy ... because I
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 13:39 — user12345Easy ... because I wanted more than "average" for my kids. I think Public school education is near child abuse. So much wasted time and potential. My four daughters accomplished twice as much in half the time as their public school peers. Now that should not be a surprise when you realize the student is getting one-on-one customized 7x24 education by a dedicated college educated loving parent. That is as good as it gets. I don't fault other parents for not educating their kids at home but I do feel sorry for them for missing such a wonderful once in a life time opportunity and sad they turned their kids over to government bureaucrats who provide Daycare for older kids in my mind. I know many parents do not have the confidence, experiences, or finances to educate their children and I feel sad for all they are missing. And I was sad seeing my kids go to Public school in HS where they were bored reciting the State provided subjects that do not challenge the mind but we were no capable of provide education in Calculus, Biology, and Chemistry and had to submit. WCPSS provides a good average Public education which is better than most counties in NC ... maybe not the level of Fairfax where I grew up but I don't live in DC, I live in Raleigh. And being average is quite good for any government organization in my mind. Ultimately, you get what you pay for ... in Wake people get a free public education, taught by government employees using government materials and books ...
Wrong...
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 09:14 — JanisTangoHe was NOT talking about the voluntary integration of the two school systems. Maybe you need to get out of Wake more. If WCPSS is such a model for success why do the other 99.99999% of the counties in this nation do something different? My children go to one of those RIM schools. I have personally seen how this policy has been destructive to these schools. They have destroyed several perfectly good schools by constantly shuffling kids. Is that your definition of success?
When my kids were "shuffled" at a "rim school"
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 19:40 — refusingtobeunkindWhen my kids were "shuffled" at a "rim school," it was because all of the people moving here from New York and New Jersey made our school too crowded. The "shuffling" had nothing to do with magnets, or with diversity. It was because there were more kids than there was space.
?
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 22:11 — Bob_SconceWhich rim school? In general, the growth has been on the outskirts -- not a whole lot of new homes being built in the rim. And, frankly, I think I've met more new folks from California here than from New Jersey. How could you tell all these new kids were from New York?
Not exactly in either case
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 19:33 — MarvinSchwartzI was not specifically referring to the integration of the Raleigh and Wake systems, but I did mean that WCPSS voluntarily pursued diversity without being ordered to do so by the courts.
So you're both wrong - and you're both right!
He was talking about
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 13:17 — virginiadareHe was talking about court-ordered desegregation. Merger of the two systems was Wake County's means to voluntarily desegregate black and white schools. How have the rim schools been "destroyed"? Because they have higher numbers of poor disadvantaged students than some other schools? Wait until you see the very high poverty racially identifiable schools that will be created by the new zone assignments. Then you will see what failing schools really are. That is what has caused failing schools in the rest of the nation, warehousing the poor.
Here's How Our School Was Changed!
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 15:57 — JanisTangoWith the constant reassignments, parents are fed up and leaving these RIM schools voluntarily. We had a wonderful school with a fantastic reputation many years ago. After dealing with constant reassignments, many people started pulling their kids out because they wanted stability. We had many go private, home schooled, charter and magnet. We have lost parental support, PTA officers, etc. We still have parent volunteers, but not the numbers we use to. Many parents cannot continue to support the magnitude of needs our school has just because we don't have the volunteers we use to. This hurts our teachers and our children. This is not limited to just our school.
When my kids were
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 19:45 — refusingtobeunkindWhen my kids were "shuffled," and the "neighborhood" school's fortunes waxed and waned as a result of the shifts, it was entirely due to the # of people moving here from New York and New Jersey; the transplants' kids we welcomed with open arms made our school too crowded.
The "shuffling," and the shifting strength/weakness ratio of parental involvement and student performance had absolutely nothing to do with magnets, or with diversity. It was because there were more kids than there was space.
Our neighborhood was a convenient size to be moved, and so kids from our node were moved several times. None seem worse for the wear now, by the way; I made friends with teachers there, who, all these years later, assure me the school affected by these shifts has bounced back as well.
One school's experience isn't the same as another's
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 21:31 — Apexter"When my kids were "shuffled," and the "neighborhood" school's fortunes waxed and waned as a result of the shifts, it was entirely due to the # of people moving here from New York and New Jersey;"
I'll take you at your word on that, and am glad that in the end, the experience worked out OK for your family.
But please realize that what you saw happening at one school does not necessarily define what happened in all other schools. My node was among one of the first NED nodes that were reassigned to a distant school for socioeconomic diversity in the first year that WCPSS officially changed its policy from one based on racial diversity to one based on socioeconomic diversity.
My (former) neighborhood, on the Cary/Apex border was reassigned to Dillard Drive Elementary. While growth in west Cary and Apex was growing through the roof at the end of the 90's, WCPSS chose to build both Dillard Drive ES and Yates Mill ES within a mile or so of existing Swift Creek ES because that location was on the "busable rim" instead of where the growth was happening.
What WCPSS didn't plan on was that the families who lived near those schools on the rim feared the instability of reassignments, and in order to gain stability, magneted out in record numbers. When we researched this at the time of our reassignment (around 2001), we found that more than 50% of the students in the base nodes living near Swift Creek ES had magneted out. Suddenly, the affluent suburban base that WCPSS had counted on being in these busable rim schools had deserted the schools, and Swift Creek and Dillard were left as seriously underenrolled schools with fairly high poverty concentrations. In other words, the nodes of the low income kids being bused in from SE Raleigh in order to go to a more affluent school were being bused into a school that wasn't really affluent anymore. As a result, WCPSS cast its net out in our direction, and our moderately affluent Apex node was reassigned to be bussed in to take the place of the neighborhood base families that had magneted out.
Having had very bad experiences due to long bus rides when I was a kid in a rural county, I had opted not to apply to magnet schools for my kids because all the magnet schools (save one) were very distant from our home. I was very upset that my kids were then reassigned from a nearby school to a distant school, so that they would be forced into a long bus ride without even the benefit of any special programs at the distant school. Growth management staff told us that we were being bused in to improve the socioeconomic balance of the school. They literally used the phrase "stinky schools" when they told us that our kids were needed there because when the percentage of low income kids in a school approached or exceeded 40%, parents had the perception that it was a "stinky school."
I'm glad that your kids weathered their reassignments well. I have 2 sons, one of who was a rising 1st grader and and one a rising 4th grader at the time of the reassignment. My older child was outgoing, and one who will bloom wherever he's planted. My younger son was, at that time, painfully shy and had difficulty adjusting to new people and new situations. His preshool teacher, his kindergarten teacher, and his physician wrote letters to the BOE stating that reassigning him to a new environment would be harmful to his development that were ignored when we applied for a transfer.
One size does not fit all. As a parent, I resented how WCPSS touted itself as a school system that offered choices when our family was offered no choices whatsoever. (Growth management denied the magnet applications of all families except for one in our group of 4 reassigned nodes that year.) This is the inherent source of discord in the system. A system where families living in the core of the county have nearby magnets as their base assignments or nearby options, while those who live at the outer edges are not only too far from the magnets to make them a viable option but also see their remaining choices reduced by mandatory year round and having their neighborhood schools diminished by being forbidden to have "electives or anything resembling an elective" is unjust. Anyone who cared to consider how systems work could clearly see that such an unbalanced system of offerings is certain to breed resentment and unrest.
Rim schools have been
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 20:04 — jenmanRim schools have been dealing with a lot of the diversity busing. They are getting the low income kids that ITB (north/west) schools do not want and there is shufflling around to 'balance' the populations at those schools. The growth and transplants have been going to the outer areas for several years now, not the rim areas.
I also disagree that the shifting & lower parental involvement had nothing to do with magnets. Magnets have taken many involved parents from rim schools, and rim schools are underenrolled, not overcrowded. Perhaps you're talking about many years ago? Or maybe we are talking about different definitions of 'rim schools'?
Thanks for the words of
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 19:52 — zandeThanks for the words of common sense and perspective refusingtobeunkind. That is exactly what I expected was happening in the rim schools. Lots and lots of transplants made the shifting necessary. Ironically, those neighborhoods were probably so attractive to transplants b/c of the WCPSS policies in place at the time. (Disclosure.. I am myself have been happily transplanted in this wonderful area since 1987. I did not attempt to radically change everything to "how we did it where I am from.")
Then how will the high
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 16:03 — virginiadareThen how will the high poverty schools have the support for the magnitude of needs they will have with no parental volunteers? That will definitely hurt their teachers and children! And the reassignments were driven by the massive growth and chronic underfunding. It was the tens of thousands of families moving here over the last decade that created the instability.
And the reassignments were
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 17:04 — jenmanAnd the reassignments were driven by the massive growth and chronic underfunding.
------------------------------------------------------
Not at the rim schools.
Yes, at the rim schools.
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 19:47 — refusingtobeunkindOur School Had Nothing To Do With Massive Growth....
Wed, 06/23/2010 - 20:22 — JanisTangoOur school is in an area of town where 'growth' is pretty much stagnate. There really isn't land left to develop. When the 3 year assignment plan came out they expected us to be at capacity after shuffling the kids. They didn't count on the number of parents that pulled children out voluntarily. My son's class of 24 lost 10 kids to voluntary moves. We went from a projected enrollment of 550 to an actual enrollment just under 430.
Ok here we go again with the
Tue, 06/22/2010 - 16:39 — user12345Ok here we go again with the Art Pope broadcast from Locke, AFP, Civitas (did you all get the phone "survey" too) and finally a posting by a Thales leader.