This morning's editorial section has a pair of competing op-ed pieces on the Wake school board races.
In the piece from Maria Mauriello, she warns "that the school system's critics want to roll back the clock on our children." She's the co-founder of BiggerPicture4Wake, which has endorsed candidates who support the diversity policy.
The opposing piece from Chris Marsch criticizes how Wake has applied the diversity policy. He's endorsing the candidates who happen to be backed by the Wake Schools Community Alliance.
BTW, Marsch had talked with the Wake County Democratic Party about running for the District 2 school board seat. Marsch has also been involved in the No Child Left Behind notification issue at Barwell Road Elementary.

Comments
okay...sorry about the 360
Thu, 10/01/2009 - 14:36 — jeannie84okay...sorry about the 360 thing...never claimed to be good at math...but I did come from a northern state where there were neighborhood schools...and I watched my parents' anger mount as their property taxes went up, up, up to fund inner-city schools while the suburban schools nearby got zilch...and that is the REALITY, people...read the historical perspective in today's N&O: http://www.newsobserver.com/opinion/story/119631.html?story_link=email_msg.
This statement particularly resonates: "Educating children in diverse classrooms is morally right, educationally beneficial and politically necessary."
You can keep talking with yourselves on this blog, but saying it won't make it so. The current system in Wake is not perfect, but we'll only be shooting ourselves in the foot to do a 180 toward a policy that is PROVEN not to work for all children, and will only result in lower property values, higher property taxes and a deteriorating quality of life.
So, what I hear you saying
Thu, 10/01/2009 - 22:31 — woodstockSo, what I hear you saying is that facts do not matter, your entire perspective is limited to Wake County and CMS, and you base your decisions on a tag line.
Additionally, what you fail to acknowledge is that it is morally reprehensible to subject children to a life of hardship because you are unwilling to address their academic and social needs.
Except right now in Wake County
Thu, 10/01/2009 - 20:31 — TrailerParkGirlThis statement particularly resonates: "Educating children in diverse classrooms is morally right, educationally beneficial and politically necessary."
Except right now in Wake County the lower income children in those diverse classrooms* are not getting educated, so its not educationally beneficial for them. BTW - when you make that statement to be fair, you should say a huge achievement gap is morally right as long as it is within a diverse classroom.
*in many cases, diverse classrooms mainly applies to elementary school here as by the time these children are in middle and high school, the low income are largely in remedial classes with few students that are different from themselves from a "diversity" perspective as defined by the "diversity" gods here. In a number of cases, they also spend two hours a day on a non-diverse bus, to get to their non-diverse classrooms and have lunch with their friends at their non-diverse table in the diverse lunchroom. Just want to make sure we are all living in reality.
interesting...Mr. Marsch's
Wed, 09/30/2009 - 09:44 — jeannie84interesting...Mr. Marsch's piece sounds like a regurgitation of WCSA/GOP talking points, complete with candidate endorsement...while Ms. Mauriello's supports her argument with quotes from Charlotte officials who KNOW what can happen to a community's quality of life when schools are re-segregated
Geez, Jeannie, are you
Wed, 09/30/2009 - 21:33 — woodstockGeez, Jeannie, are you kidding? That is all Mauriello and the status quo talk about, Charlotte this, Charlotte that, and "resegregation." It has reached a point of being a mindless mantra. The world of solutions is bigger than the the status quo acknowledges.
The truth is the reassignment for diversity policy is harming the very students it is intended to help -- that is supported by the pitiful graduation rates of the economically disadvantaged (ED) student subgroups. The policy has been in effect for a decade and the graduation rate for ED students sits at 54.6%. If your child had only a 1 in 2 chance of graduatiing, would you sit back and want more of the same, or would you demand change? Most people would choose change.
This school board race has gotten too political. Even some educators just can't let party politics go and do what is right for the students of Wake County. I will never understand that.
Please look at the facts...and the status quo's deceptive characterization of Charlotte does not represents all the facts. Guilford County for example (3rd largest school system in NC) has instituted programs that has raised the graduation rate of the their ED students to 72%, which is nearly 16 percentage points higher than Wake.
I know it is difficult to break away from your political tendencies, but this is about educating our children and helping them succeed and it extends far beyond mere partisanship.
sounds like you're repeating
Thu, 10/01/2009 - 08:13 — jeannie84sounds like you're repeating your own mantra with those same alledged statistics..."hello, kettle...this is Woodstock...you're black." Charlotte is Raleigh's reality if we do a 360 and follow their misguided lead.
Bang, bang, bang - me banging my head against brick wall
Thu, 10/01/2009 - 09:56 — TrailerParkGirlHey for the Door #1 and Door #2 and if we move away from Door #2, we can only go back to Door #1 crowd - THERE'S DOOR #3. There's a whole big, wide world out there with more than two places in it called Raleigh and Charlotte. There's also this thing called innovation, meaning you chart a new path, clear a new trail. Innovation is why we are blogging over the internet and not sitting around in cave, banging rocks together and grunting at each another.
Some years ago here (I say here because where I'm from has always operated in a community model) the education wheels were rectangle. The city and county systems were separate, resources were segregated. This was not good, the cart could not move forward, so the systems were combined. Then rather than reallocate resources to where needed (other than magnet program) and address underlying challenges, we went to square wheels - moving the students around (including removing low income students near magnet schools from those schools where the resources were put). The lack of improvement in STUDENT achievement, tells us that the cart still is not able to move forward with square wheels.
We need ROUND wheels, what's behind Door #3 - community schools like what John Tedesco has been advocating from day 1. Have you checked them out - www.communityschools.org? They work. Community schools are round wheels. They move the cart forward. They put the resources where needed and use them more efficiently through public-public and public-private (community service orgs)partnerships, in addition to PTA. They make school the center of the community to help build up the community by putting needed resources together, and by addressing underlying challenges in higher poverty areas. In higher income areas, the community school is more like what one typically thinks of as neighborhood schools where the private support comes via PTA/local residents. Where I'm from, additionally people who live in higher income portions support (money & time) lower income portions.
Another reason community schools work is that those involved believe in these kids, families and communities instead of saddling them with low expectations and defeatism like much of what I hear from the status quo side. They can't do it, they can't be healthy, Low income Larry must go to school with Big Bucks Biff in hopes that Biff will somehow rub off on him and to hide Larry's scores behind Biff's (because deep down we think Biff is better than Larry and Larry can't accomplish as much as Biff), mediocre is the best we can do, it can't be done, well yes some others are doing it, but here we'll just go backward blah blah blah.
If you don't believe in them and the possibilities, please just kindly step out of the way of those who do because your way is not working and never will as it's focus and attitude are all wrong. If you haven't seen it yet go to youtube and check out the video "Do YOU believe in me?" These kids, families and communities need people to believe in them, as they need to believe in themselves and their possibilities in order to move their cart forward.
"Aledged statistics?"
Thu, 10/01/2009 - 11:25 — woodstock"Alledged statistics?" Interesting point of view, completely wrong, but intersting in that purposefully ignoring facts is a strange concept for me.
But, fortunately for you, you do not have to take my word for it, check out the information for yourself at:
http://ayp.ncpublicschools.org/2008/app/cgrdisag/
Take a look at the student subgroup graduation rates for each H.S. in Wake County. Take Leesville High for instance; it is generally consdered to be a very good school, but even there only 50% of ED students graduate. The reason is a bus ride does not address the very real challenges these children face. If you really support students and education, how can you stand for that?
By the way, a 360 degree turn puts you right back where you are.
Hello? Hello? No
Thu, 10/01/2009 - 08:38 — JSBinNCHello? Hello? No 360.
Maybe 55. or 70. or 113. Whatever degree of change needed to ensure opportunity for every child.
It WCPSS that's stopped building on what they started. They got to the point that the "right" schools looked good enough to keep the money flowing. Everything - and everyONE else - be damned.
That's not good enough for me - and it shouldn't be good enough for anyone.
You must have missed the the very last sentence of Mr. Marsch's
Wed, 09/30/2009 - 10:59 — TrailerParkGirlpiece. Where it says Christopher W. Marsch is the father of two students at Barwell Road Elementary School.
How familiar are you with the Barwell Road area situation Jeannie84? You might consider taking off the rose colored glasses for a bit and doing some research.
Mr. Marsch is speaking from his own experiences. He understands the reality about what goes on here in Wake County.
Ms. Mauriello took Larry
Wed, 09/30/2009 - 09:51 — Eric_BMs. Mauriello took Larry Gauvreau's quote out of context and is probably ignorant of the fact that he was one of the drivers behind Charlotte's end to forced busing. His position is 100% opposite of her's and he's trying to get Charlotte to reform further from where they are now.