WakeEd

The WakeEd blog is devoted to discussing and answering questions about the major issues facing the Wake County school system. How much will the new Democratic majority on the school board do to undo the changes made by Republicans since 2009? Will the new student assignment plan be a hybrid of the last two models or primarily be a return to the use of busing for diversity? Who will replace Tony Tata as the new superintendent of the state's largest district? How will voters react to a likely request in 2013 to borrow potentially more than $1 billion to build and renovate schools?

WakeEd is maintained by The News & Observer's Wake schools reporter, T. Keung Hui. While Keung posts information and analysis on the issues, keep us posted on your suggestions, questions, tips and what you're doing to cope with the changes in Wake's schools.

Choose a blog

Calling Tuesday's election results a mandate for community schools

Bookmark and Share

Republican members of the Wake County school board are calling the GOP sweep of the commissioners races a referendum showing support for pushing ahead with community schools.

As noted in today's article, GOP school board members say that people did respond to the calls from Democrats to turn it into a referendum on the school board's student assignment policy changes. The result, board members say, is a message that they've got the community's support for their actions.

“The people are saying, ‘Leave the school board alone; let them do what they were elected to do on student assignment,’” said school board member Chris Malone. “People want the school board to succeed and do their business.”

School board chairman Ron Margiotta was even more emphatic on that point. He said it should embolden all five Republican board members, including Debra Goldman, to move forward on community schools.

Margiotta said he wants the Oct. 5 directive halting work on the zone plan to be amended.

Margiotta said he's also going to push for something more than just making a few more node adjustments next year or only looking at the reassignments scheduled for next year. He said he wants to start using the new Policy 6200 to eliminate what he thinks are the most flawed examples of the use of diversity in student assignment.

Democrats tried to downplay the meaning of Tuesday's election results on the school board.

“I certainly don’t see it as a referendum on the community wanting neighborhood schools or more reassignments,” said school board member Keith Sutton.

Democrats are trying to attribute the GOP sweep of the four board of commissioner seats to the national Republican wave as opposed to support for the school board's policies.

"It’s a reflection of the national mood as it’s playing out at the county level," said Mack Paul, chairman of the Wake County Democratic Party. "Voters who are motivated by school situation were out, but they were too small a segment of the voter population.

Paul argued that the real test of public sentiment will come in next year's school board elections.

Margiotta isn't buying that argument at all. He said Democrats and other supporters of the diversity policy can't walk away from their repeated efforts to turn this year's election into a referendum on the school board. He singled out the leadership of the Great Schools in Wake Coalition, state NAACP, Wake Education Partnership, Greater Raleigh Chamber of Commerce, Capitol Broadcasting and The News & Observer.

"Local issues dominate local elections,” Margiotta said. “The number one local issue has been the schools. That’s what the other side kept pounding on. This was a direct referendum on the school board.”

School board member John Tedesco also pointed to the election results in Wake showing how well Democrats did on Congressional and General Assembly races. He said that wouldn't have been the case if there was such as large local GOP wave as Democrats insist.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

How do you push ahead with no majority?

I support the school board, for the most part, but I don't see this as a mandate. If the CC's feel they are on the right path they are more likely to listen and work together, but that isn't clear yet. It can't be clear after you start forward with big changes and then stop dead in your tracks because you didn't see the blind sided smack coming at your head.

I think it's pretty clear that everyone is going to take some hits with the huge budget cuts. Hard choices and unpopular decisions are going to be made and many will not like it. Mr. Matthews told me last week that the school board won't get a free pass and will have to do more with less like everyone else.

What does Ron mean when he says he wants the directive amended? Why has it taken a month to ask to amend it? Making more than just node changes for next year sounds interesting, but such as?

If the school board sees a mandate here then fine. Get on with it and give in to Goldman or get her to meet in the middle, but get it done and let's end the assignment discussion by putting a new plan into place next year for all of Wake County.

Then maybe we can move on to improving education!

The Race to the Bottom

FS,

I agree that the BOE should be focused on improving education - but how and with what resources? Its obvious that the BOE and most other political factions are focused on the heated topic of assignment policy. That's important, but not the only issue on the horizon.

As of the end of June, WCPSS may have to lay off 2,000 teachers and staff. This is based on a $120 M short fall from 2010-11 to 2011-12. This is 11% of the operating budget (largely teaching and learning). If that forecast materializes, it is likely that WCPSS will have to struggle to maintain the existing quality of education. A teacher on this blog has reported 30 students per class. That is contrary to previous standards and raising quality by giving each child individual attention. 

$86 M of the shortfall comes from the expiration of Federal grants. The outlook for continuation of such grants is very low. These grants offset the State's drop in funding for WCPSS of $81 M over the last two years.

An additional $34 M cut from the State is forecast. The state is running a $3 billion to $4 Billion deficit that must be closed in the coming session of the General Assembly. The Governor has ordered every department to prepare budget scenarios defing 5%, 10% and 15% budget reductions. I have opted for the least of these - but the cuts could go deeper. As the BOE and the BOC and the General Assembly are now governened by Republican majorities, shouldn't the BOE be leading the lobbying effort for added funding?

Some here have said its up to the County to close the gap. But the County's budget is very tight due to lack of growth in the property tax (both the rate and the base) and a large fall-off in sales tax revenues - largely related to the continuing high unemployment rate. The county provides funds for other important services.  Is there anyone here who is for cutting public safety, libraries, EMS, public health initiative for the mentally and developmently disabled, inititiatives to deal with a syphlis epidemic, child mental health, school nurses, initiatives that deal with homelessness, hunger, AIDs, protection of our water supply, etc. etc?

County management has tightened its belt over the last two years and can be expected to do so again in the coming year, but such belt tightening is likely to only offset cuts in State Funding for Human Services and unfunded mandates from the State.

So what are potential solutions to cutting 2,000 teachers and staff.? A property tax increase is highly unlikely. The BOC's majority campaigned against any increase. The prospects of the quarter cent tax increase earmarked for teachers  (= two and one half cent increase in the property tax rate = $27M) allowed by the GA, look dim in light of the failure of passing identical referendums elsewhere in the state last week.

  • The BOE hasn't sold the extra acreage around H6, the abandoned Forest Ridge site, the HQ building and the other school properties involved in the so-called savings involved with the move to Crossroads. The estimated value is roughly $15 M assuming buyers can be found. In normal times these funds would have been returned to capital - but they could go into the classroom.
  • The choices become more difficult from here. YRS save both operating and construction costs. The BOE jointly with BOC could stop building standadrd schools. Trailers and modular units could replace standard construction for all growth requirements. Standard construction cost roughly $25,000 per seat. As a SWAG, mobil and/or modular units on existing school sites could be under $4000 per seat. At 4,000 new seats per year, the savings savings could be over $80 M per year. Cash savings to the County for debt service could reach  $7 M per year and one-time equity savings could be $15 M. Again, cash savings could be spent in the classroom. 

These options require intensive joint discussions between the BOE and the BOc and their staffs. These are not occuring.

If anyone has further ideas I would like to hear them. I have stayed away from options within WCPSS. The outlook is bleak and not enough attention is being paid to this critical situation.

Thank you for keeping us

Thank you for keeping us informed ... so sad ... the BOE is arguing over zones and diversity and they are about to be clobbered with big revenue shortfalls and increased students ... it is like watching a hurricane hit is slow motion ....  prepare, prepare ... if the Republican leadership is not going to show any preparation leadership we need to make sure to pin the resulting problems on them ... when students show up to overcrowded schools with +40 kids in a class, the top teachers let go, no grass on the football field, few AP courses, etc. we need to direct them to Ron and team who will still be hunkered down fighting the diversity wars ...

Truly Sad

In addition to the diversity war, Ron is concerned about market share - trying to lure back the students who left the system for religious and other reasons brought about by advances in technology, at a time when we do not have proper funding for the 140,000 students in the system. 

The Republicans for years have claimed millions of $ of waste in the system, yet this new board has not identified one nickel of net savings in the almost one year they have been in office and it does not appear anything is in the works.  The $20m of transportation savings that would have resulted by the "new" assignment policy was quickly dropped - no word of it now. 

 

If Mr. Mathews said that, he

If Mr. Mathews said that, he has a very shorted view of things. Education should bethe  last thing to be cut. Education is the answer to a lot of the challenges we face economically and socially and it directly impacts the what we spend on welfare programs, law enforcement and the criminal justice system ....better, more inclusive, education will reduce what we need to spend on those things.

Right On the mark

Well said Woodstock...

I would also add since education should be the last to be cut, we should expect WCPSS to be held to the highest possible standards in wisely spending our tax dollars.

If the school board sees a

If the school board sees a mandate here then fine. Get on with it and give in to Goldman or get her to meet in the middle
 
I'm all for getting on with the assignment discussion, and stepping up the academic discussion.  But I don't think the other "majority" members know where the "middle" is for Goldman.  Right now, she is simply the party of no.  She has said she does not want zones (but assignment areas are ok?) and wants base assignments (are "Base options" ok?).  She has not elaborated what she does want, and until she does the "middle" can't be established.  If what she wants is to go with the Hill plan, then you can write off any meaningful changes in how we do assignment planning.

I don't see it

The GOP sweep had some impact, but was not a direct referendum on the school board.  When I voted for the County Commissioners, I did not focus on each candidate's stance on school assignment.... that's not their job. 

The school board election next year will be the referendum on the BOE.  I'm voting for someone who can work constructively with others,and get something done to improve student achievement, regardless of political affiliations.

Glad you ignored all the articles, blogs, political mailers, etc

you may not have focused on it but certainly everyone else was talking about this as these other departments i.e. county commissioners and their actions would either faciliate? (for lack of a better word) or resist as many of the new School Boards policies as possible. So indirectly yes it is not their job but cooperation is needed with a lot of other agencies/departments to get things changed -e.g. see NC legislature and the "non-segregation" legislature -which was comical. 

Whenever the segregation is borught with repsect to neighborhood schools, I am bemused that they are not picketing or protesting the segregated neighborhoods or towns - is it because the towns and neighborhoods are not segregated and this is just political posturing? 

I think so.

I must confess,

I trashed every political mailer I received... but I did read the blogs and articles;  All of the CC candidiates supported education, in one form or another, therefore, I focus on their stances on other issues. 

I may be wrong, but the issue is not segregated neighborhoods, but segregated schools.  Nevertheless, I am willing to support zone assignments if it will reduce student re-assignments.

....

"The school board election next year will be the referendum on the BOE."

What about last year's election? It seems many keep saying "Just wait until the next election. Then we'll show you."

 

 

You're right.... elections count.

I agree.... By the next election, we will have an opportunity to assess the results of the BOE and determine if we agree with the direction (or lack of) the BOE is headed, and vote accordingly.

Cars View All
Find a Car
Go
Jobs View All
Find a Job
Go
Homes View All
Find a Home
Go

Want to post a comment?

In order to join the conversation, you must be a member of newsobserver.com. Click here to register or to log in.

About the blogger

T. Keung Hui covers Wake schools.
Advertisements