Greg Cox gave Herons, the restaurant at the Umstead Hotel and Spa, five stars. This is the first five star review since he moved to a five-star system. Read it HERE.
Want to post a comment?
In order to join the conversation, you must be a member of newsobserver.com. Click here to register or to log in.About the blogger
Andrea Weigl has been the food writer at The News & Observer since the summer of 2007. She has won a handful of awards from the Association of Food Journalists and the Society for Features Journalism. Her profile of chef Ashley Christensen titled "A Force of Nature" will be published in the sixth edition of "Cornbread Nation: The Best of Southern Food Writing." She is serving a three-year term on the James Beard Foundation book awards committee. Follow her on Twitter at @andreaweigl.Advertisements

Comments
Herons - over-rated!
Thu, 03/18/2010 - 15:00 — ldegrandIt's been almost a month and I remain most disappointed by our experience at Heron's. Four of us went there, primarily based upon your review. First of the disappointments - the vaunted service outside of the restaurant was no where to be found. Indeed, we even had difficulty finding the restaurant after entering the hotel and no one ventured to assist us. Then we were told we could not be seated until the appointed reservation hour - fifteen minutes away and with the restaurant half empty when we were finally seated. We whiled away the minutes in the bar area waiting for someone to take a drink order. My husband finally had to go to the bar itself to place an order since no one came to our table. When the designated reservation time came we were escorted to the restaurant but carried our bar drinks in ourselves. I believe you noted that this service was provided for you. Not a biggie - but still.Once in the restaurant the service was fine, but then issues with food arose. The winter mushroom soup was excellent. However, my venison was bland, in spite of the promised cranberry, etc., sauce. The accompanying sweet potatoes were equally without flavor, lower than tepid in temperature (like the venison). Presentation was "interesting." The venison marched along one side of the plate, the sweet potatoes on the other. In the plate's middle was a very large white emptiness. The others, who ordered the fish entree and the pheasant seemed to fare a bit better. However, we all agreed that the restaurant was definitely not worth a return visit when Raleigh's Bloomsbury Bistro and Durham's Magnolia are available.