Blogs

newsobserver.com blogs

Replay Caulton Tudor's live chat on the ACC in the NCAA tournament

  Join columnist Caulton Tudor to discuss N.C. State, UNC and Duke in the NCAA tournament (03/12/2012)
11:51
Lorenzo Perez, moderator: 

Welcome, everyone. Columnist Caulton Tudor is joining us to discuss N.C. State's return to the NCAA tournament, UNC and Duke's matchups in Greensboro and the rest of the bracket.

Monday March 12, 2012 11:51 Lorenzo Perez, moderator
11:57
[Comment From Caulton TudorCaulton Tudor: ]

Hi folks. It's a busy Monday. The NCAA ruling on UNC football situation will come down later today, and The N&O will cover the story thoroughly. But for now, let's limit this conversation to basketball. State, UNC and Duke will open NCAA play Friday.

Monday March 12, 2012 11:57 Caulton Tudor
11:59
[Comment From Oliver PurnellOliver Purnell: ]

Caulton, normally, I would expect to see a lot of press about Henson's wrist, but no one seems to be saying much about it. (remember Lawson's toe in '09 ???) What is Henson's status?

Monday March 12, 2012 11:59 Oliver Purnell
12:00
Caulton Tudor: 

Well actually I thought there was a lot of attention devoted to the injury. It will be covered as the week goes along too. Roy Williams said Henson could have played Saturday and Sunday but there really was no reason to rush his return.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:00 Caulton Tudor
12:01
Which ACC team will go the farthest in this year's NCAA tournament
North Carolina

 
 ( 54% )

Florida State

 
 ( 15% )

Duke

 
 ( 19% )

N.C. State

 
 ( 12% )

Virginia

 
 ( 0% )
Monday March 12, 2012 12:01 
12:01
[Comment From SBSB: ]

Hi Caulton - Many sports journalists have mentioned the poor officiating in the tourney. With their silence, the ACC office appears to be content with it. In your opinion, do you think anything will be done? What do you think should be done?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:01 SB
12:03
Caulton Tudor: 

I certainly think there should more in the way of explanations from the league. It's the same throughout sports -- NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL, even PGA. There's a gag order complete with heavy fines for anyone publicly criticizing or questioning officials. The ticket buying customers deserve more insight than that.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:03 Caulton Tudor
12:07
[Comment From GuestGuest: ]

Sounds like Ryan Kelly may not be back. How far do you think Duke can go in the tourney without him?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:07 Guest
12:10
Caulton Tudor: 

I don't think the situation with Kelly is settled yet. It's still early in the week and Duke shouldn't need that much Friday against Lehigh. It'd be nice for him to play enough to get live-game feel back. But Sunday against Notre Dame or Xavier, the Blue Devils would need him. Even so, in Greensboro on familiar turf, Duke should get to Atlanta whether Ryan's back this weekend or not. Don't forget that with a lot going wrong with the offense Saturday, Duke still had a chance to beat Florida State at the end.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:10 Caulton Tudor
12:10
[Comment From jakejake: ]

Fla. State was 4 - 1 against Duke and UNC, ACC Tourny champ, yet they got a 3 seed?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:10 jake
12:12
Which No. 1 seed will get bounced from the tournament first?
Kentucky

 
 ( 5% )

North Carolina

 
 ( 27% )

Michigan State

 
 ( 32% )

Syracuse

 
 ( 36% )
Monday March 12, 2012 12:12 
12:13
Caulton Tudor: 

But you just cannot erase the fact that FSU lost to Harvard and Princeton. I thought a No. 3 was spot-on. Plus, I think the Noles should have a fairly easy second-round game against Texas or Cincinnati. On paper, neither of those teams have the size and depth to deal with FSU. The big problem this weekend for the Noles could be the Noles. They have to pretend they're still facing UNC and/or Duke.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:13 Caulton Tudor
12:14
[Comment From SteveSteve: ]

What are the chances that we will UNC v. NCSU Part 4?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:14 Steve
12:15
Caulton Tudor: 

I can actually envision a scenario in which both get to St. Louis. But even if the Pack gets past Sunday against either Georgetown or Belmont, that likely would lead to Kansas in a building that will be packed with KU fans.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:15 Caulton Tudor
12:16
[Comment From GuestGuest: ]

Big debate between a couple UNC fans and myself (Orange fan)... Does the depth of the Big East (9 teams) show that it's a more powerful conference than the ACC (before realignment)?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:16 Guest
12:18
Caulton Tudor: 

I think so. I think the Big East has been the best basketball conference overall for the past several years. The ACC has been a 2-car garage. Those 2 are limos, of course. But otherwise, the ACC hasn't had a lot pop in the middle of the standings.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:18 Caulton Tudor
12:19
[Comment From benben: ]

What weaknesses do you see in the other #1 seeds?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:19 ben
12:23
If you're a UNC fan, what football punishment would you accept in exchange for a guaranteed NCAA basketball title this spring?
Five-year bowl ban

 
 ( 23% )

Two year TV/bowl ban

 
 ( 38% )

Loss of 25 more scholarships

 
 ( 8% )

Five more straight losses to N.C. State

 
 ( 15% )

Football program death penalty

 
 ( 15% )
Monday March 12, 2012 12:23 
12:23
Caulton Tudor: 

Michigan State's offense can be iffy. If you lose 42-41 to Illinois, there's an obvious downside. Syracuse - like UNC - sometimes has trouble guarding the 3-point arc. Kentucky has the best talent, but John Calipari still hasn't won one anyway. If Duke had won the ACC Tournament, I think the Blue Devils would have been the fourth No. 1 -- over Michigan State.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:23 Caulton Tudor
12:23
[Comment From BillBill: ]

Florida State certainly looked rugged and game-tested. Do you think their game will translate to the NCAA tourney, as far at Elite Eight?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:23 Bill
12:26
Caulton Tudor: 

Not really. I think FSU has as many tools as any of the No. 2 seeds, and more than the other No. 3s. But this is a team that seems to lose its focus unless the opponent is UNC or Duke. I think the Noles should win two games for sure.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:26 Caulton Tudor
12:26
[Comment From Jalen R.Jalen R.: ]

It does not look very favorable for NC State to move on, as San Diego State clearly is the better and more experienced team. Wouldn't it have worked out better for the Wolfpack if they had earned a NIT bid?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:26 Jalen R.
12:27
Caulton Tudor: 

No. I think anytime you get an NCAA bid, it beats the heck out of the NIT.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:27 Caulton Tudor
12:28
[Comment From JasonJason: ]

If Kansas and UNC meet for elite 8 what do you think the outcome will be. It def. will be packed with KU fans.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:28 Jason
12:31
Caulton Tudor: 

It would be a lot like a road game even in St. Louis. But if UNC has Henson back in decent health, the Heels probably would be a 1-to-3 point favorite. A big key for UNC is Harrison Barnes. He was all that on-target in ACC Tourney. He got most of his points on follow shots and free throws. I don't think he's banged up or leg weary, he's just not been very effective with the ball.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:31 Caulton Tudor
12:31
[Comment From Oliver PurnellOliver Purnell: ]

Jalen's question got me thinking...has a team ever turned down an NCAA tourney bid in order to play in the NIT? If you are 16 seed, wouldn't you rather have a chance to hang an NIT banner rather than get blown out by a #1 seed?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:31 Oliver Purnell
12:33
Caulton Tudor: 

Marquette turned down the NCAA a couple of times in the early 1970s. Al McGuire hated the selection committee. But then in '77, he took the NCAA bid and beat UNC in the title game in Atlanta.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:33 Caulton Tudor
12:34
[Comment From jdunc5783jdunc5783: ]

How are the officials selected each year? If there have been reviews of every game (so we're told), then would a high number of questionable calls demand the official be replaced?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:34 jdunc5783
12:36
Caulton Tudor: 

There's an officiating committee. There is no juror ejection process, though. The NCAA supposedly reviews the officials throughout the year in an effort to get the very best for the tournament.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:36 Caulton Tudor
12:36
[Comment From GuestGuest: ]

Whom do u think will turn pro after the season is over from duke, unc, and state

Monday March 12, 2012 12:36 Guest
12:40
Caulton Tudor: 

I have to think all of the UNC guys will go -- Barnes, Marshall and Henson. I do think that if Henson decides to return, Marshall would consider it too. If Heels win the NCAA, though, I think they'll all go. With Duke, the only question in my opinion is Rivers. I'm beginning to think he'll come back for one more year. Mason Plumlee, I think, will come back. He could slip into the 2nd round if a lot of big guys from overseas enter the pool. CJ Leslie, I think, will leave at State. That said, he's really enjoyed working with Gottfried's staff, so it's not a cold lock he'll leave.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:40 Caulton Tudor
12:40
[Comment From AnonyAnony: ]

Do you think any of the officials from this weekend's ACC tourny will be selected for the NCAA? If so, do you think their semi-biased towards teams based on officiating this weekend?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:40 Anony
12:42
Caulton Tudor: 

Roger Ayers will be there. Probably Les Jones, Tum Nestor. The big question now is Brian Dorsey. He obviously had a bad performance Saturday in the State-Carolina game. Karl Hess will be included. Bernard Clinton probably. You have to remember that 180 to 200 officials will work NCAA games somewhere this week.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:42 Caulton Tudor
12:43
[Comment From Peter in RaleighPeter in Raleigh: ]

Why has Barnes been so passive?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:43 Peter in Raleigh
12:45
Caulton Tudor: 

I don't think he's confident handling the ball in perimeter traffic. He gets stripped of possession and/or disrupted a lot more than I thought would be the case after two seasons. He'll probably be better in the NBA, where hand-checking is basically outlawed.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:45 Caulton Tudor
12:46
[Comment From HeelsHeels: ]

Mason Plumlee? He will never be drafted, ever. Get real Caulton.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:46 Heels
12:47
Caulton Tudor: 

Most of the mocks have him at the bottom of the first round right now. But there are always more overseas players who wind up in the draft than anyone predicts in February and March.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:47 Caulton Tudor
12:51
[Comment From GuestGuest: ]

Do you think Swoford regrets bringing Syracuse into the ACC in light of the allegations against them?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:51 Guest
12:54
Caulton Tudor: 

Swofford didn't bring those schools in. The 12 current ACC schools made that decision based on advice primarily from ESPN. The motivation behind expansion and realignment has very little to do with anything except a desire to annex cable TV systems in the largest possible cable TV markets. That's why the ACC probably will go 16, then 18. It's dumb through and through, but it does bring in more TV loot to the schools -- for now. Eventually, it'll collapse from within.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:54 Caulton Tudor
12:55
[Comment From markmark: ]

Any early word on San Diego State and NCSU's respective travel schedules? The time change could present a problem for SDSU in particular, with such an early tipoff for a West Coast team.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:55 mark
12:56
Caulton Tudor: 

Both teams will be Columbus on Thursday for practice. State will probably practice here Wednesday, have a meal and then charter to Ohio.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:56 Caulton Tudor
12:56
[Comment From ChuckChuck: ]

has any team had as many quality wins on the road or on a neutral site as Duke this season? Beat a #1 and #3 seed at their place, and beat a #1, a #2 and a #4 seed on a neutral court?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:56 Chuck
12:57
Caulton Tudor: 

Nope. Duke's road resume is better than any other team.

Monday March 12, 2012 12:57 Caulton Tudor
12:57
[Comment From Jalen R.Jalen R.: ]

As Florida State proved this year, the ACC is an extremely weak conference, which only helped to inflated the gaudy records of UNC and Duke. Based on previous reputation, Duke and UNC received favorable seeds over deserving teams, such as Missouri, Kansas, Ohio State, and Marquette. Do you understand that UNC and Duke's previous history has allowed them to be given a more favorable seed every year?

Monday March 12, 2012 12:57 Jalen R.
1:00
Caulton Tudor: 

There's probably something to that, based on the ACC's lack of depth the past few years. But at the same time, Duke and UNC generally have played aggressive non-ACC schedules. Most of the other so-called "major" conferences have slipped.

Monday March 12, 2012 1:00 Caulton Tudor
1:01
[Comment From frankfrank: ]

UNC appeared to have found good chemistry prior to losing Henson in the ACC Tourney. Additional experience for other guys, notably McAdoo and Watts could give added confidence and depth headed into the NCAA Tournament. On the other hand, it could be disruptive if McAdoo along with the usual suspects are thinking too much about draft stock. Do you see any potential chemistry issues, especially now that Marshall is not giving up his own shots to spread around as much?

Monday March 12, 2012 1:01 frank
1:03
Caulton Tudor: 

No. I think UNC's chemistry is fine. The ACC tourney gave Hairston and McAdoo a glimpse of what's ahead. The big UNC question -- to me -- goes back to Barnes. If he has a big NCAA tournament, I think the Heels will get to the Final Four as long as Henson is in acceptable health. He doesn't have to play 35 minutes, but Henson's defense is important against big front lines.

Monday March 12, 2012 1:03 Caulton Tudor
1:04
[Comment From GregGreg: ]

I think CJ Leslie is good enough to carry State very far...He just seems on the brink of becoming a superstar now that he is finally buying into what the coaches have been teaching. Do you think he is capable of getting State to the Elite Eight?

Monday March 12, 2012 1:04 Greg
1:07
Caulton Tudor: 

I still think State's big question is the 7-man rotation, because Leslie and Howell simply get into foul trouble. And Saturday, C.J. Williams got into early foul trouble against UNC. Leslie is playing lights out, no question. If State could ever get to the second half with no more than two fouls on each of the starters, the ceiling would be much higher. But the most unpredictable thing in basketball (other than injuries) are fouls.
Thanks for the questions from all. Our time is up and it's going to be a hectic day and a hectic week. We'll do this again soon. So long for now.

Monday March 12, 2012 1:07 Caulton Tudor
1:12
 

 
 
 

UNC vs. N.C. State: Join our live chat

Just a reminder, in case you hadn't already seen our promotion, that The News & Observer today at noon is hosting a live chat about the North Carolina-N.C. State game. So come on out and join me and Joe Giglio, our N.C. State beat reporter, at noon.

You can access the chat at www.newsobserver.com/sports. See you there.

NCAA tournament live chat with Ken Tysiac

Assuming he can tear himself away from the "make your own waffle" buffet line at his Anaheim hotel, Duke beat writer Ken Tysiac will be online with us at noon to discuss tonight's Duke-Arizona matchup in the NCAA West Regional semifinals, as well as anything else related to the tournament.

Click here to join the conversation.
 

Replay Thursday's ACC basketball chat with Joe Giglio

Get a replay of Thursday's noon chat with staff writer Joe Giglio as he discussed UNC's win over N.C. State, the Wolfpack's future and all things ACC hoops.

NCAA tournament live chat

Join us at 11 a.m. for an NCAA tournament live chat with staff writer Ken Tysiac, who will be joining us from Jacksonville, Fla. this morning as he prepares for Duke's opening-round matchup with Arkansas-Pine Bluff.

Questions about your bracket? Wondering how Wake Forest escaped Thursday night (or Friday morning, really) with an overtime win over Texas after blowing double-digit leads in the first and second halves?

Join the discussion by clicking here.

ACC Tournament Live Chat, part three

We have live chat addict Ken Tysiac with us online until 11:45 to talk about yesterday's ACC tournament action, as well as about what to expect in today's quarterfinal games, starting with Duke-Virginia at noon.

Join the live chat here.

ACC tournament live chat

Looks like N.C. State will be the state of North Carolina's last chance to advance a team into the second day of the ACC tournament.

Join college basketball writer Ken Tysiac for a live chat tonight, as Ken sits courtside at the Clemson-N.C. State nightcap in the Greensboro Coliseum. 

Click here to join the chat.

ACC Tournament live chat at noon

GREENSBORO — Don't forget to join N&O sportswriter J.P. Giglio online at noon today for a live chat from the Greensboro Coliseum.

Please keep him company as he suffers courtside at the Greensboro Coliseum during the first half of the No. 8 Boston College-No. 9 Virginia game.

Click here at noon to join the fun.

College basketball live chat

Join staff writer Ken Tysiac online at noon for a live, hour-long chat on ACC basketball.

With six league games scheduled for this weekend, including Duke's trip to Georgia Tech, N.C. State's home game against Virginia and UNC's home game Sunday night against Virginia Tech, there's plenty to discuss.

To jump in, click here.

Playoffs live chat at 2

The next installment of "Chat with Chip" will begin at 2 p.m.

To join the live online chat and talk Hurricanes hockey, go to here.

Cars View All
Find a Car
Go
Jobs View All
Find a Job
Go
Homes View All
Find a Home
Go

Want to post a comment?

In order to join the conversation, you must be a member of newsobserver.com. Click here to register or to log in.
Advertisements