American Idol (8pm, Fox) - In their annual effort to make viewers feel really old, tonight 'American Idol' will have finalists perform songs from the year they were born. Garner's Scotty McCreery was born in 1993, so I came up with a few suggestions for him: "Rump Shaker" by Wreckx-N-Effect, "Whoomp! (There It Is)" by Tag Team, or the club hit "What is Love" by Haddaway (that's right, 1993 was not a good year for popular music). Actually, my serious prediction for Scotty would be something like "Have I Told You Lately" by Rod Stewart or "To Love Somebody" by Michael Bolton (both remakes). Our 'Idol' blogger Thad Ogburn has his own (more realistic) predictions. Check out his "Scotty Watch" and submit your own suggestions for what all the 'Idol' hopefuls should sing tonight. Then tune in to see what happens.
Criminal Minds (9pm, CBS) - Prentiss prepares for a final showdown with her nemesis, Ian Doyle, and the team asks J.J. to return and assist them as they try to help Prentiss.
Justified (10pm, FX) - Three robbers, led by an aging ex-con who has emphysema and a history with Art, hold up a bank while Winona is in it. Meanwhile, the marshals question Boyd and Ava about the robbery at the coal mine office.
Top Chef All-Stars (10pm, Bravo) - It's down to four chefs in the Bahamas, where the remaining contestants must cater a high-end lunch party for a yacht club's 80th anniversary and serve up Bahamian delicacies, including conch, which they themselves must first catch in the ocean. Lorena Garcia is the guest judge.
Hot in Cleveland (10pm, TV Land) - Elka tries to persuade Max (Carl Reiner) to spend the winter in Cleveland instead of going to Florida. Meanwhile, Victoria falls for a man (Gregory Harrison) she meets during a TV interview.