On June 27, I posted a link on my Facebook page to a short story on the Town Council’s decision not to charge a library fee for non-Chapel Hill county residents this year. I teased into it by saying council members Matt Czajkowski and Laurin Easthom, who voted for the fee, were “not happy.” Easthom gave us permission to publish her Facebook comment.
It wasn't just Matt Czajkowski and I that were "unhappy."
Former Mayor Kevin Foy fought for years to achieve fiscal equity between the county and the town on library funding, to no avail. He also had an excellent working relationship with the county. He and I talked a lot about this issue.
Town Manager Roger Stancil and the town staff recommended instituting a fee. A great many citizens in this community who lived outside of the town limits that I talked to were fine with paying the fee and looking forward to a newly expanded library.
Don't forget Stancil's budget message looking to the next couple of years, advising that there would be a property tax increase due to JUST the library's increased operational costs, born solely by the citizens of Chapel Hill (in addition to other potential increases).
I support tax increases for increased services generally. But when the financial burden is on Chapel Hill, footing 100 percent of the capital costs ($14 million-plus) and providing library services basically for free to Carrboro residents and others in the county who don't pay property taxes for the library like we do in Chapel Hill, it just seems unfair.
As I said in the meeting, the vote was to continue to subsidize those that live outside of Chapel Hill for use of the town's library. It seems we are basically engaging in an inevitable merger process between the county and the town library systems all in the name of "interoperability." Wonder what will happen to the "increasing" county funding to the Chapel Hill library when the county opens the Southwest (Carrboro) library branch it has been planning. Maybe by that point we will be merged.
What is interoperability anyway? What are the costs to the Town? How are fuzzy numbers and vagueness "my friend" in this process as council member Sally Greene stated.
If books are shipped out of the town's library to Hillsborough, is there a reduction of copies and reduced availability to those that use Chapel Hill's branch? Will more books be purchased to offset this sharing? Who bears these costs? Is it solely the county?
If a merger is beginning in our systems, then does the county ever reimburse the town a portion of the $14 million we paid to expand the Chapel Hill branch? Does anyone care about the $14 million that Chapel Hill paid? Or the over $2 million in costs to run the library in the first year it's expanded (and subsequent tax increase to pay for that)?
I sure would have liked to have given more money to deserving, hardworking nonprofits in our community this year in our budget, and not cut some of them like we did (like the YMCA afterschool program). Heaven knows what will happen in future years with a still sluggish economy and a tax increase on our table as Stancil has predicted.
I guess the council felt that financially helping those in Carrboro and other county areas use our library was the right choice. Perhaps when I look back I will breathe a sigh of relief that it all worked out. But today I'm the skeptic.