Choose a blog

Tudor: Time for 'Rivers' award

Bookmark and Share

Ordinarily, I'd be the first to say we need another post-season college football award the way we need another television time-out during game coverage.

This is different, though.

This one could be ours  — "ours"  being the great collective gang of in-state fans who follow teams from the Triad to the Atlantic Ocean. We could even throw in Metro Charlotte, but that area has an award and it's an important one — the Bronko Nagurski honor presented annually by the Charlotte Touchdown Club to the nation's top defensive player.

Totaled, by my unofficial count, there are 24 awards to players and coaches. There's an award (Rimington Trophy) for the outstanding center, kicker (Lou Groza Award), punter (Ray Guy) and almost everything else.

There is not, however, an award that I can find anywhere to recognize the nation's best freshman player each season.

It's a void the Triangle could — and should — fill in my opinion. Listen up, Raleigh Sports Club, Durham Sports Club, and anyone else with a free ear, enough mad money to design a fitting trophy and a few minutes to read on.

Assuming we can all just get along — "all" being in alphabetical order Duke, ECU, State, UNC and Wake Forest fans — long enough to agree on one subject, the perfect person to name the national freshman of the year award for would be Philip Rivers, the former Wolfpack quarterback.

Rivers, as a freshman in 2000, started every game, completed roughly 54 percent of his passes for 3,054 yards and 25 touchdowns. By the time his college career ended, he owned many of the passing records in the ACC and nationally.

He did while being a model athletic citizen, role model, legitimate student and team leader. I know there are lots of other deserving candidates from these parts, but Rivers is completely qualified and deserving of an award in his name.

But initiating a national freshman award comes with another plus — unlike most awards, there wouldn’t a predetermined group of potential winners.

In almost all of other categories, particularly the Heisman Trophy, it's difficult for a preseason long shot to gain enough attention and momentum to land a lot of votes at season’s end. Freshmen are different.

Oh sure, they arrived with various 5-star, 4-star, etc. recruit ratings, but lots of 5-stars turn out to be slow starters while lots of 3-stars (Rivers) excel immediately. The details would have to be ironed out, but that could be done quickly by the organizing committee.

It'd be a cinch to have this thing up and running by the start of the 2010 season. The winner could be announced in January and an award banquet held shortly thereafter.

I say let's do it, before some other community does.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

ACC Now - Tudor: Time

ACC Now - Tudor: Time for 'Rivers' award | newsobserver.com blogs How Grow Taller

Actually...

Replace Weinke with Woody Dantzler.

Worst is a toss up between Marcus Stone and Harrison Beck.

No toss up

Harrison Beck hands down.

Too bad he quit football. He would have been perfect for the Cleveland Browns.

Would it be...

for the best freshman or best true freshman? I dont think RS freshmen should be included.

Best ACC QB's that I have seen...
1. Phillip Rivers
2. Charlie Ward
3. Joe Hamilton
4. Matt Schaub
5. Chris Weinke

Who?

Who is this Philip Rivers guy you speak of?

Just kidding of course. PR was an outstanding freshman and seemed to be a good role model. I just don't know how he compares overall with, say Charlie Ward, first ACC QB Heisman Trophy Winner.

I'm a UNCer and have always

I'm a UNCer and have always been a big fan of PR. Caulton has my permission to initiate the award ASAP.

There always is a danger in so honoring a player who is still active. Its 2009 and every day brings a headline about some pro athlete getting into trouble that might besmudge his legacy.

I doubt that would happen w/ PR but I never figured such for Roger Clemens either.

Tudor is nuts...

...but I've got no problem with a Philip Rivers award. He would be the undisputed best QB in ACC history if not for mediocre records (11-3 and a Gator Bowl was the only season where the team as a whole had a lot of success). He re-wrote the NC State record books (not bad for a school that produced Roman Gabriel, Eric Kremer and Jamie Barnette) and the ACC record books.

Any way, I know the article is about a freshman award, but I just wanted to throw that in there just to show that the name deserves something. He was a great leader as a freshman (nearly a 400-yard effort in his first game, as well as a 24-point comeback to beat Minnesota in his first bowl). He's always been a big trash talker, but he backs it up. Time to give him some recognition.

Mediocre record.

Can you imagine what the Pack's record would have been if Philip hadn't been there? We didn't know for sure what a lousy coach Chuck was until he was gone.

Smoke and Mirrors

The Smoke and Mirrors facade did vanish rather quickly without Rivers at the helm. My folks inside that program said a lot of the discipline quickly went away without Mr Rivers there to jump onto people for horsing around--I know it's not a stretch to believe such an assertion. I wish Mr Rivers would've gone over to the defensive side of the ball to maintain some discipline. Thank goodness TOB has those young men in order now.

 Oy. Still kills me that Rivers never beat Maryland. I do hate some Maryland fans. It's also funny that Rivers is Mike O'Cain's greatest recruit. It's even funnier that Wilson may be Amato's greatest recruit. Oh well. Go Pack!

Correction

We've got to give credit where it's due.  Wilson would not be wearing the red and white if it wasn't for Elliott Avent.  He held Marc Trestman by the neck and said "if you dont offer this kid, I will kill you."  Maybe not to that extreme, but that was the idea.

Ugh.

I hope he had a hammer in hand, we all know how hardheaded and prideful Red Shoes and Co. were. 

Let the haterade spill

Rivers' name would be a great one to attach to such a deserving reward. However, I'm sure the haters are about to rain down with "just" statements as to why Rivers doesn't deserve to be attached to such an honor.

Cars View All
Find a Car
Go
Jobs View All
Find a Job
Go
Homes View All
Find a Home
Go

Want to post a comment?

In order to join the conversation, you must be a member of newsobserver.com. Click here to register or to log in.

About the blogger

Joe Giglio covers the ACC for the News & Observer, where he has worked since 1997.
Advertisements