Choose a blog

Davis' future bigger than Tennessee

Bookmark and Share

Tennessee is the latest school to desire Butch Davis' services and the Volunteers won't be the last to court UNC's football coach.

In two seasons, Davis has been, or will be, pursued twice, each time by an SEC school.

Last year, it was Arkansas, Davis' alma mater, and a program where he still has close relationships with the school's powerful donors.

Davis resisted the emotional and financial pull of Arkansas for any number of reasons, the one that's being most overlooked is his calculated decision to come to UNC in the first place. Davis knew he could make hay in an average conference at a school with low-pressure demands on its football program.

Let's be clear, Davis can coach. UNC was one of the 10 worst programs in the BCS era before Davis arrived. In less than two seasons, Davis has the Heels 7-2 and ranked in the top 20.

But the ducks all lined up in a row for Davis, too, at UNC, just as he predicted when he chose UNC over other college openings in 2006.

After essentially quitting as the Cleveland Browns coach with five games left in the 2004 NFL season, Davis spent two seasons out of football.

He left the NFL with $12 million still owed to him by the Browns. Details of that buyout never became public but it's reasonable to assume Davis pocketed half of that.

That's $6 million to NOT coach football, in addition to the $3 million Davis made annually with the Browns for the three seasons he was on the sidelines. Clearly, money was not, and likely is still not, Davis' primary motivating factor. I'm not arguing it doesn't matter, just that the dude's got cash.

So why would he choose UNC? The short answer is the ACC. With Florida State and Miami on the downswing, and the name-brand recruiting recognition of Carolina, Davis realized he had the path of least resistance to the top of the college football world.

Think about it, and Davis' agent Jimmy Sexton admitted as much in his comments last month in Birmingham:

If Davis took a job in the SEC, he would have to bang heads with powers Florida, Georgia, Alabama and LSU. And that's not to mention the second tier of Auburn, South Carolina and Tennessee.

In the ACC, there's who? Virginia Tech? Clearly, Davis did the math before he took the UNC job. Remember, he chose UNC over returning to Miami, where he built the Hurricanes into the best program in the country at the end of the 1990s and into the 2000s before leaving for Cleveland in 2001.

With Davis' original intent in mind, there are few jobs he would leave UNC for. Save for Florida, and that would be awkward given his Miami background — although not impossible based on Rick Pitino's precedent in college basketball — there likely isn't a job in the SEC that Davis would take.

That leaves, in order:

1) University of Texas

Texas Tech, Missouri and Kansas have all made noise in the past two seasons but the Big 12 is essentially the Big 2 — Texas and Oklahoma.

Given Davis' past at Oklahoma State, I'm going to rule out Oklahoma — which also fired Davis' right-hand man, John Blake, so I don't think the two would be eager to run to Norman.

Davis recruiting at Texas is a frightening proposition. The 2001 Miami team, that won the national title the year after Davis left, was, from No. 1 through No. 85, the most-talented team in the history of the game.

He could give that roster a run for its money with Texas' recruiting resources and rich talent base.

Of course, Mack Brown is the coach at Texas. But Brown, after 11 seasons and a national title in Austin, could take another job or leave coaching to get an AD or commissioner job.

The pressure would be greater to deliver at Texas than at Chapel Hill, but Brown handled the transition and so could Davis.

2) Dallas Cowboys

The Cowboys have a coach-in-waiting in offensive coordinator Jason Garrett, but at 5-4 the Cowboys are in danger of missing the playoffs, after beginning the season as the Super Bowl favorite.

Don't think Dallas owner Jerry Jones, a fellow Arkansas alum, wouldn't dump Garrett and blow the whole staff up in a Texas minute if the season continues to crash and burn.

Davis spent six seasons as a defensive assistant with the Cowboys, helping head coach Jimmy Johnson and Jones win two Super Bowls.

The Cowboys would be appealing to Davis on two fronts: this is not an expansion situation, which is what Davis walked into in Cleveland. This is a Super Bowl-ready franchise with an owner that will do whatever it takes to win.

I don't know the details of Davis' relationship with Jones – Johnson, Davis' mentor, parted hastily and famously with Jones in 1993 — but we know Davis and Jones have a history together.

Then there's Davis' ego. Check out the hallway to UNC's media room if you need proof of that. There's a larger-than-life poster of Davis that greets you when you step out of the elevator at the football center.

Big egos can't handle 24-35, which is what Davis went in four seasons at Cleveland with one playoff appearance. The more people who tell Davis he can't coach in the NFL, that he's just another Steve Spurrier or Pete Carroll, the more he'd be inclined to prove people wrong.

3) Penn State

It's a longshot but it would at least be worth a conversation. Like the ACC, the Big Ten is ripe for domination. There's Ohio State and not exactly.

On the verge of another Big Ten title, Joe Paterno has reconfirmed that his successor will be his call and Davis won't be his choice.

But replacing a legend never works — like Frank Solich, like Ray Perkins — so the PSU search committee would have to cast a wider net in 2010.

Interestingly enough, Paterno almost took the Miami job when Davis was ultimately hired in 1995.

4) USC

Talk about owning a conference, please, Carroll owns everything west of Austin.

Los Angeles might be a little out of Davis' comfort zone, but it's an unbelievable recruiting base and you're guaranteed an annual crack at the national title.

Plus, at USC, there's no NFL team in LA and no one really cares about the basketball program.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

All the Best

My Best wishes go out to him, and to his friendsFat BurnDude

He seems great, I hope he is

He seems great, I hope he is doing okay.
Mike - burning fat
drivercure dude.


None of the options in the article are right. I agree whole-heartedly with gvillegatr -- Davis is right where he wants to be and we are right for him. As Giglio said, that's why he's here. Ego or no ego, the man is after a legacy. Jumping around or taking over a successful program is not a legacy. Brown built his legacy, but he had to go to Texas to complete it. Davis can build and complete his here in Chapel Hill. (And, yes, "if only" Brown had been given the same resources Davis is now! But Davis will finish.)

I remember when Brown got the Texas offer a friend at work (who was a local semi-pro player and friend to the Carolina coaching staff -- prowled the team sideline during home games) predicted Brown would never leave. A few million wasn't enough to lure him into the fire that is Texas football. WRONG! In Davis' case, he's built, is building and is tending his own fire. He stays.

If money isn't...

the motivating factor, then why did he ask for the raise last year after a paltry record?

If the heat of competition in the SEC is so enormous then why would he go to the "laid back atmosphere" of the NFL?

Not following your logic on this one.

As other sportwriters and analysts i've read have mentioned, the success of UNC-CH this year probably has more to do with the players Bunting recruited than any of the staff's coaching acumen.  Except for Davis, these guys have all had miserable records as coaches.   Not to mention the ACC has horrid offenses this year.

nc recruiting

Yeah, people confuse the recruiting abundance in Texas, Florida, California with that of NC all the time. double butch's salary and we would triple in population overnight. he does not need 3 or 4 great players a year, but 25. let's celebrate a "year early" season. a win at Md and the Orange Bowl seems possible if we get some help.

You're right

He could stay, this is basically a list of where he could go. I just don't think the SEC is play.


hhhmmm ....

The University of Texas would be too damn easy for Davis. fish in a barrel.

Jerry keeps his word (in the beginning) or Garrett would be at Miami (I'm a Dolfan!) right now instead of Sparano. lets think the good Lord its Sparano ... whose a better puppet than Garrett anyway. also, Coach davis and JJ were tight. I'd be willing to bet that relationship trumps Jerrys even though he is an Ark alum (so is JJ for those keeping score at home). please see Coach Davis saying "no thanks" to Ark last year.

Penn St is as simple as the weather at Coach Davis' age. like young recruits, old people dont want anything to do with cold weather either! cold weather jobs are for locals and people trying to make hay on their way up. Coach Davis is neither.

USC, or SC as I call them, has zero focus ... or they would go undefeated every year. Coach Carroll is the most care free coach ... which is why it is a perfect fit for him (Carroll). Coach Davis is not very care free in my "outiders" opinion and would be frustrated (pulling out hair) by the first days end.

In summation, Coach Davis is right where he belongs at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill in Austin, TX. sounds crazy but its true. UNC can do anything Texas can in football IF given the resources. Coach Davis is getting those resources right now. It's a damn shame no one did this for Coach Brown ...

 I did enjoy the article though ... just wanted to counter/rebutt.  kinda like what you and "Toots" used to do!

Cars View All
Find a Car
Jobs View All
Find a Job
Homes View All
Find a Home

Want to post a comment?

In order to join the conversation, you must be a member of Click here to register or to log in.

About the blogger

Joe Giglio covers the ACC for the News & Observer, where he has worked since 1997.